Second Fiddle
When my parents brought their second child home from the hospital (which happened to be me), they walked up the front steps of our home and found an irrefutably clear statement from my older sister Julie regarding her feelings about being the big sister. Julie pooped in the middle of the front porch. She was only two and a half years old, but had apparently mastered the concept of how to communicate metaphorically. She didn’t use the words “like or “as�, but rather, a giant pile of toddler doodie, to effectively communicate her feelings about sharing her parents. Using the power of fecal sculpture, she said “this is precisely what I think of you people and that ridiculous funny-looking creature you insist on bringing into my house.�
I think she felt a little jilted. I can’t blame her. I didn’t sign up for my place in the family order either. But hey, I am here, and that's a good thing. I think.
When I was young and stupid, as opposed to being grown-up and stupid, I was sure I would end up with a gaggle of kids. As I grew older, reality set in. I had a hard time juggling life before I became a parent. I currently have a hard time juggling life with one child. How on God's green earth am I going to throw another kid into the mix? Who do I think I am anyways? In addition, that whole childbirth thing was really a drag. I came home from the hospital with a third degree tear and crippling baby blues, and said “NEVER AGAIN. One is going to have to be enough.� As my daughter would say: “Aah-dun!� I was glad to be off of that scary ride, thank you very much.
I suspect that any woman who says she loves to be pregnant is lying through her teeth. Either that, or she possesses a gene that I just never got. I am the kind of person who would just as soon skip the pregnancy and childbirth part and start out of the gates with a 6 month-old.
I don’t want to go through it all again. It was exhausting the first time around, and I am 2 years older and more decrepit now.
But there, in the back of my mind, is a niggling that won’t go away. I grew up second in line out of four sisters. I like to say that I got so shortchanged, I even had to share the title of middle child.
However, for every pity-party I threw for having to share resources, money, clothes, and my parents attention (which happened on a near-daily basis), I have thanked heaven about 50 or 60 times for the sisters I have today. By the time I am an old woman, that ratio will likely have quintupled. I would not trade a single one of my sisters for anything. And I mean anything. Not all the tea in China, or all the riches in the world.
Having my three sisters is like having a lifelong membership in a club of mutually insane people. We grew up in the same crazy family, and share the same wacky sense of humor, rife with things like off-color “Little House on the Prairie� innuendos and a fascination with the weird. We are irreverent, off-the-wall, and we find ourselves and each-other endlessly entertaining. We tend to share similar neuroses, though the manifestations vary. They just make me laugh. With them, I always fit in.
My family would have been so different if my parents would have stopped at one. Who am I kidding? I wouldn’t be here if they stopped at one. I can’t speak for my older sister Julie, although I hope she agrees that the sacrifices were worth it. Each addition to our family brought another unique child into the mix. I read once that in families with more than one child, every kid essentially grows up in a different family. The family morphs into a new, crazy work of art with the addition of each unique personality. That always made sense to me. I don’t want to know what life would be like without a single one of them.
I am afraid though. I am afraid that I am not a good enough mother to one child. If my time and energy is divided further, how could I possibly keep it together? How can I give my kids their fair share of my time and attention? How can I distribute the love fairly? How could I love another child as much as I love my daughter? Can we afford it? Is it fair to Maggie to have another baby? Is it fair to any of us to risk stretching myself too thin?
I don’t have the answers. I do believe that life takes you where is it is supposed to, when it’s supposed to. It might be time to think about getting back on the scary ride. Perhaps fate will intervene and make the decision for me.
Only time will tell.
If we do have another child, and if Maggie chooses a form of expression similar to that of my older sister Julie, I will explain to her that she can poop on the floor all she wants. It’s okay to feel mad. That sibling is her team-mate for life, and she can make that relationship what she wants. I will tell her that if she is anything like her mother, when she is my age, she will thank her lucky stars for the gift of a sister or brother. Perhaps by then, she will want to save her doodie for other, more important statements.

















Comments
Having a second was amazing. Although there are moments of defiance and anger from my oldest, he looks for his younger brother and wants him around most of the time.
Posted by: Kari | March 30, 2006 11:41 AM
OMG, I am so grateful for your post, Meghan. I have been feeling exactly the same way, asking myself the same questions. My son is 2, and I had several months of post-partum depression after he arrived. I keep waiting for the day in which I'll finally feel successful at being a mom. He is thriving, but I never feel like I have it all together. On the other hand, I grew up with two sisters and I don't want to deprive him of the chance to have at least one sibling. Some days, I really want to have another child. Other days, I'm not so sure.
Posted by: surcie | March 30, 2006 11:57 AM
I feel the same way, though not about the pregnancy part (which I really did enjoy due to no morning sickness). Unfortunately, I am infertile, so to have that other one means even more scientific assistance. We have nine embryos in the freezer, but I'm so unsure regarding how to juggle with two, and my husband and I were pretty old to begin with. Sigh. This is a question I ponder often, usually daily.
Posted by: abogada | March 30, 2006 12:06 PM
I'm envious of your relationship with your sisters. I'm estranged from mine.
Posted by: Carmen | March 30, 2006 12:29 PM
I was adopted at age 2 and have 6 brothers and sisters that I don't know anything about. I was adopted into a family and have 2 adopted (blood to each other) brothers and no sisters. I always liked having my older brothers protect me when I was younger, but they are 6 and 8 years older than I am so we didn't have a lot in common and as they got older we didn't talk much at all...they still thought of me as a "kid". anyway I wouldn't trade them for the world, now.
I can honestly say that I had 3 super easy pregnancies and truly enjoyed being pregnant and would love to have a few more kids in the future...I know I am crazy with 3 already, but I love being a mom and the whole bit.
Good luck in your descision, but I truly think you can handle all the kids God gives you...have faith in yourself. both of the books sited are a wonderful read.
Posted by: Paula | March 30, 2006 2:05 PM
I don't know how many times I have said/posted/cried the same thing. I've decided to own the fact that I don't want more than one child. Any family is the family experience that will be "normal" for my daughter, and I like my life the way it is now. And I think that's okay. So does China. Whatever you decide to do, just own it and feel good about it. Not everyone gets along with siblings. There are no guarantees they would be peas in a pod. If the only reason you'd have another is to have another (which is the only reason I would), then is that the right reason, either?
Posted by: Dorothy | March 30, 2006 4:30 PM
Thank you so much for this post!
The same questions have been racing through my mind since we have been thinking about adding on to our family.
I never thought I would have so many fears and concerns about bringing another person into this world.
Thanks again.
Posted by: Adria | March 30, 2006 11:02 PM
There's been no strategic defecation at our house, but there has been some whining on occasion.
It was unnerving before/during the pregnancy. It was really hard during the initial weeks and months of having two children. But now, most of the time, it's lots of fun.
But two is enough for me.
Posted by: Julie | March 31, 2006 12:43 PM
I have three daughters. Not one of them was intended by me, but God listened to my life plans and laughed hysterically. Then He gave me what I needed! Essentially, I am raising myself times 3. My only sister and I are 18 months apart, and routinely bloodied each other until we grew up and married our husbands. Now we are best friends, and we come from the same shallow gene pool.
With three daughters who are redheads on the inside, my life may be many things...but never boring!
Posted by: Erin (erin-erin-bo-berin) | April 1, 2006 7:25 AM